Official GIGABYTE Forum

Maxtor drive is so noisy it sounds like typewriter?? Is this normal for Maxtor?

ZIGGATRON IV

  • 7
  • 0
  • Life, but not as we know it....
Hi, I have purchased a second hand MAXTOR STM3320820AS SATA 300 8MB buffer...

The thing I am concerned about is the level of noise coming from the drive during reading and writing ops..

The drive sounds more like a typewriter than a HDD.

The drive is clearly audible outside the case over any noise emitted by the 9800 gt gpu fan, cpu fan and cooling fans.

the problem is this system is for sale as an entry level gaming machine and I do not want to sell anything which is sub-standard or not genuinely in good condition.

I have a fair amount of experience across most areas of PC building and repairs but I have never had a potential problem with an actual HDD before that relates to noise, so I need a stronger opinion from some one who has a more solid background in HDD mechanics.

My initial interpretation would be the heads are out of alignment or worn or etc etc etc but really I would only be guessing.

I always end up using Seagate drives, of which none make any significant noise and are pretty silent.

Maybe Maxtor drives are renowned for being exceptionally noisy??

the drive is loud enough to be disturbing and anyone who bought the system would unavoidably notice it immediately and query it with me.

If it's normal for a Maxtor drive, that's fine, I will tell them that is the case.

If it's a sign that the drive is excessively worn and poses any sort of question as to the reliability of the drive in the short/medium term then I will have to ask for a refund and return the drive...

Thanks for your help.
« Last Edit: March 08, 2013, 07:02:59 am by runn3R »
Life can seem impossible but strength of spirit does and will always prevail.. Never, ever, ever, ever give up, you will get there. :-)

Vezina

  • 871
  • 10
  • If it s not broken, fix it until it is !
Yes ,such noise is perfectly normal for Maxtor.
Unfortunately Seagate took over Maxtor and  i can see similar behavior on a 640Gigs HDD :)
I ve seen such things on many friends PC-s with Maxtor drives.Do not put sensitive data on Maxtor drives.
If you ever have booting issues give it a mild hit or hit the case.

With Seagate and WD noise amount really depends on the model.

 
Over & Out !

AMD FX (APU-s included) users should install - KB2645594 & KB2646060 under Windows 7

1.ASUS Sabertooth 990FX 2.0 + FX 6300 + H60
2.MSI A88X-G41 PC Mate + A8 5600K + Hyper TX 2
3.Gigabyte F2A75-D3H + A4 5300
4.ASUS AM1M-A + Athlon 5150

 

anything