A single pin was bent 180 degrees from where it should be, with no other pins being disturbed. How is that even possible? The only thing I can think is that perhaps the metal bracket fell and hit the pin just right as it did fall one time as I was opening the lever. I reopened it, dropped the CPU straight in and clamped it shut.
I was able to bend the pin back into place (with a ton of patience, a magnifying glass, and a needle). It took a few hours as I had to be extremely careful not to disturb any other pins. I put the CPU back in and sure enough slots 3 and 4 were working. I'm now worried about the socket as a whole, especially integrity issues with that pin.
Do you know of any extreme stress testing I can do CPU wise to ensure everything seems okay? Intel Burn Test maybe?