I've seen this issue as well.
In 'advanced' settngs, I ensured the topmost setting was 34.
For the 4 individual settings, I changed each one top-down.
e.g. (40, 39, 38, 37 for 1-core, 2-core, 3-core, 4-core).
I then saved successfully.
Changing the settings at random did seem to cause "AUTO" to repopulate, which was weird.
I can say, for my board, GA-Z86X-UD4, upgrading to the latest BIOS (F9) resolved a number of other issues - for your board, did you update to the latest BIOS ver?